Is Modernity Compatible With Hindu Values
Is modernity - with its secularism, rights-framework, and assault on varṇāśrama dharma - compatible with Hindu values, or structurally hostile to Hindu civilization?
#culture
#modernity
The debate of tradition vs. modernity is now common in any society. Though the definition might not be clear to many, modernity’s effect is seen worldwide and thus every society witnesses its clash with tradition, and is in the dilemma of what to keep and what to jettison while proceeding into the future. While it is fashionable for many to argue that tradition and modernity can co-exist, the tension between the two is self-evident. In India this debate becomes more complex as India is one of the last ancient civilizations on earth still functioning as living systems.
Some scholars say that since secularism, a major component of modernity, is a product of a very Christian problem, hence modernity also has Christian underpinnings - and thus not ultimately good for Hindu society. Another group of scholars think that modernity is a novel invention of industrial revolution and scientific revolution in early modern Europe, but since it put an end to a Hindu society practicing varnashrama dharma it has been lethal to Hindu values and Hindu society. This big question will delve into this extremely difficult question and will present the view of the major stakeholders to the readers.
Also See
blog
Hinduism in the Blind Spot - Part 1
Part 1 - why Hinduism sits in the blind spot of open-minded, progressive Western intellectual discourse, from a structural failure of the secular liberal framework to perceive non-Abrahamic religion on its own terms.
blog
Artificial Intelligence is Here - Part 2, from Now to Henceforth
Part 2 - a proactive Dhārmika framework for navigating artificial intelligence - neither uncritical adoption nor reflexive rejection, but a principled engagement grounded in the Indian understanding of consciousness and purpose.
blog
Artificial Intelligence is Here - Part 1, from Before to Now
AI arrives as a non-neutral civilizational event - a comparison of simulation theory, Vedānta, and modern physics asks whether the intelligence emerging from our machines is something the Dhārmika tradition already has a vocabulary for.
blog
Indic Environmentalism - A Balance between Tradition and Innovation
Sanātana Dharma's environmental ethic is central to it - an argument that the dhārmika relationship with nature provides a more coherent ecological framework than either Western environmentalism or techno-optimism.
external-article
Azaan and Freedom of Expression - Are They Compatible?
The Sonu Nigam controversy as a test case for a structural question: whether the Islamic claim to unrestricted public religious expression can coexist with the Hindu majority's right to uninterrupted private space.
external-article
The Truth and the Humbug in Greta Thunberg's Climate Change Speech
Separating the genuine environmental alarm in Greta Thunberg's speech from its ideological packaging — what the climate movement gets right, what it gets wrong, and why the solution requires hierarchy and dharma rather than equality and activism.
external-article
Why Saba Naqvi is Afraid of Mullahs on TV - And Why We Must Encourage That
The internal contradiction in secular Muslim commentators opposing mullah visibility on TV — what Saba Naqvi's discomfort reveals about who actually speaks for Indian Muslims, and why Hindu society should want the authentic voice to be heard.
book
Heidegger and the Inquiry into Technology
Essay using Heidegger to interrogate technology, modernity, and civilizational critique.
book
Hindu Studies in a Secular Academy
Reflection on the institutional framing of Hindu studies and the limits of secular academic categories.
book
Jews and Hindus in Indology
Comparative study of how Jewish and Hindu traditions have been handled within modern Indology.
book
The Crisis of Hinduism
Reflection on modern challenges facing Hindu civilizational confidence, continuity, and self-understanding.
book
Hinduism Ancient and Modern
Comparative overview of continuities and changes in Hindu tradition across historical periods.